The Difference Between Contemplation and Contemplation

Sunrise over misty mountains, a steaming teacup and three books representing Buddhism, Judaism and Christianity, with the article title The Difference Between Contemplation and Contemplation.

One word, two very different experiences, and a journey through Buddhism, Judaism, and Christianity in search of something beyond thought.

I woke up this morning with my mind already running.

Thinking, thinking, thinking.

Before I had even gotten out of bed, thoughts were arriving, one after another. Some were memories, some were concerns, some were ideas about things I might do. My mind was busy making its usual commentary about life.

So I sat in meditation.

And as I watched these thoughts arising, I remembered something I had learned from the Tibetan Buddhist teacher Chögyal Namkhai Norbu.

The thoughts themselves were not necessarily the problem.

There was no need to make them stop.

In the Dzogchen teachings, thoughts can be understood as expressions of the mind’s clarity, rather than something fundamentally separate from it. What matters is our relationship to them, whether we become caught up in their movement or recognize their arising without grasping.

As I sat there, I began reflecting on something that had confused me for many years.

What exactly is contemplation?

It seems like such a simple question.

But after decades of studying and practicing within several spiritual traditions, I had discovered something rather remarkable.

The word contemplation can describe two profoundly different experiences.

And for a long time, I hadn’t understood the difference.

When Contemplation Means Thinking

Most of us are familiar with contemplation as a form of deep thinking.

We contemplate a difficult decision. We contemplate the meaning of life. We contemplate a passage from scripture, a philosophical question, or something that happened during the day.

We take a subject and give it our sustained attention.

Perhaps we examine it from different perspectives. We consider its implications. We ask questions, explore possibilities, and gradually develop a deeper understanding.

This can be a beautiful and valuable activity.

Indeed, much of philosophy, theology, and spiritual inquiry depends upon this capacity to reflect deeply.

But notice something about the experience.

There is a subject being contemplated.

There is the activity of thinking about that subject.

And there is a sense of someone engaged in the contemplation.

The mind is doing something.

Even when our thoughts become extraordinarily subtle, there remains an object of contemplation, something toward which our attention is directed.

For many years, this was the meaning I repeatedly encountered when people spoke about contemplation.

But it was not the only meaning.

When Contemplation Means Something Else Entirely

My understanding began to change through the Dzogchen teachings of Chögyal Namkhai Norbu.

Namkhai Norbu made a distinction between meditation and contemplation that was enormously helpful to me.

As I came to understand his teaching, meditation often involves a method. We may focus attention, observe the breath, practice visualization, work with a particular object, or use other techniques to cultivate recognition and stability.

Contemplation, in the specific Dzogchen sense he was describing, is something different.

It is not primarily an activity of thinking about something.

Nor is it simply concentrating more deeply.

It points toward resting in the natural state, without deliberately constructing an experience or maintaining an object of attention.

This was a revelation for me.

For years, I had been hearing people use the same word while describing experiences that seemed fundamentally different.

Now I had a way to understand why.

One form of contemplation involves the mind considering something.

The other points toward recognizing the nature of mind itself.

And this second meaning was what I had been searching for.

The Mind That Wants to Meditate

There is something almost comical about the mind’s efforts to become quiet.

We sit down to meditate, and immediately the mind begins offering suggestions.

Perhaps I should concentrate harder.

Perhaps I should breathe more slowly.

Perhaps I should stop thinking.

Am I doing this correctly?

How long have I been sitting?

And then, of course, another thought appears:

I really shouldn’t be thinking so much.

Now the mind has created a problem and appointed itself responsible for solving it.

I have spent many years becoming familiar with this little performance.

Living with myalgic encephalomyelitis, or ME/CFS, for more than three decades has also given me plenty of opportunities to observe the relationship between my mind, my body, and the circumstances of my life.

There are days when even ordinary activities require careful attention to my limited energy. And there are mornings, like this one, when the body may be resting while the mind seems determined to run a marathon.

For a long time, I could easily regard the activity of the mind as something interfering with meditation.

But the teachings I encountered through Dzogchen invited another possibility.

What if thoughts did not have to disappear?

What if their arising was not, in itself, evidence that something had gone wrong?

What if awareness did not need to be manufactured by the mind that was trying so hard to find it?

These questions gradually changed my relationship with meditation.

Vrittis, Pratyayas, and the Movement of Mind

In my studies of yoga philosophy, I had also become interested in two Sanskrit terms: vritti and pratyaya.

Broadly speaking, vrittis refer to movements or modifications of the mind, while pratyaya can refer to mental content, cognition, or the object presented in awareness, depending upon the philosophical context.

These terms are not identical to the terminology of Dzogchen, but they helped me become more attentive to what was happening in my own experience.

A thought arises.

A memory appears.

An image forms.

An emotion passes through awareness.

Sometimes I become absorbed in these experiences. At other times, I notice them without becoming quite so involved.

And increasingly, I began to appreciate a simple distinction.

Observing the activity of the mind is not the same as being carried away by it.

There is no need to turn every thought into a struggle.

Nor is there a need to regard every mental movement as an obstacle to spiritual practice.

In Dzogchen, however, the recognition of rigpa, or primordial awareness, involves more than merely observing thoughts with equanimity. That distinction matters. Ordinary mindfulness and the direct recognition of the natural state should not simply be treated as interchangeable accomplishments.

For me, the practical discovery was more modest.

I could begin loosening the habit of identifying so completely with whatever happened to arise.

And perhaps, through practice and appropriate guidance, become more familiar with the awareness in which these experiences appear.

A Similar Question in Jewish Mysticism

My exploration of contemplation also led me into Jewish mystical teachings, particularly the Chabad tradition.

There I encountered two important concepts: hitbonenut and bittul.

Hitbonenut is often translated as contemplation or meditation. In Chabad practice, it traditionally involves sustained reflection upon divine ideas, seeking not merely intellectual understanding but an understanding that reaches the heart and transforms one’s relationship with God.

Bittul, sometimes translated as self-nullification, points toward a transformation of the ordinary ego-centered sense of separateness and self-importance in relation to the Divine.

I remember hearing about the importance placed upon extended contemplation before prayer.

I also remember conversations in which rabbis described contemplation in terms of the ability to remain with a particular thought for a very long time.

That always left me wondering.

Was the purpose simply to become extraordinarily skilled at sustained thinking?

Or was the thinking intended to bring about a transformation that went beyond the activity of thought itself?

I began to wonder whether the relationship between hitbonenut and bittul offered a clue.

After all, much of our ordinary mental activity revolves around the familiar concerns of the self.

I want this.

I don’t want that.

I need this.

I am afraid of losing that.

What will happen to me?

What do other people think of me?

The possibility of loosening this self-centered involvement reminded me of something I was discovering in my Buddhist practice.

But I want to be careful here.

Chabad’s understanding of hitbonenut is not simply Dzogchen contemplation under another name. Its theological foundation, methods, and relationship to God are distinct. Nor would it be fair to assume that teachers who emphasize sustained intellectual contemplation have somehow missed the point of their own tradition.

What interested me was the possibility that profound reflection might help transform the very sense of self that ordinarily does the reflecting.

Perhaps contemplation, in one sense, could help prepare the ground for an experience that could no longer be adequately described as thinking about something.

That possibility fascinated me.

Be Still and Know

Christianity offered another doorway into this question.

One of the most familiar passages in the Bible comes from Psalm 46:10:

“Be still, and know that I am God.”

This is a verse from the Hebrew Bible, shared with Christianity through the Old Testament.

In its original scriptural setting, the passage concerns God’s sovereignty amid conflict and upheaval. But it has also become deeply meaningful within Christian contemplative spirituality.

And I can understand why.

There is something about those words that seems to invite a different quality of knowing.

Not necessarily knowing through analysis.

Not accumulating more information.

But becoming still enough to receive what cannot always be reached through intellectual effort.

Of course, that is a contemplative interpretation of the verse, not a claim that its original authors were teaching Dzogchen or a particular technique of objectless awareness.

Still, the invitation speaks to me.

Be still.

How often do we approach spiritual life as another project to accomplish?

Something to understand.

Something to achieve.

Something to become.

And how rarely do we allow ourselves simply to be present?

Samuel and the Art of Listening

Another biblical story has stayed with me over the years.

It is the story of the young Samuel, found in the third chapter of the First Book of Samuel.

Samuel is serving under the priest Eli when he hears someone calling his name.

Naturally, he assumes it must be Eli.

He gets up and goes to him.

But Eli tells him that he has not called.

Samuel returns to bed.

Then it happens again.

And again.

Eventually, Eli recognizes what may be happening and instructs Samuel how to respond.

When the call comes again, Samuel answers:

“Speak, for your servant is listening.”

I have always loved this story.

There is something touching about the young boy who hears but does not yet understand what he is hearing.

And there is something equally beautiful about the older teacher who eventually recognizes what is happening and helps the child respond.

For me, the story illustrates a movement from trying to figure something out toward becoming receptive.

Samuel does not receive an elaborate intellectual explanation of God.

He is invited to listen.

The biblical account is about prophetic calling, not a formal instruction in nondual awareness. Yet its image of receptive listening has remained meaningful in my own contemplative journey.

Sometimes I wonder how much of spiritual practice involves learning to recognize what we have been too occupied to notice.

Meditation and Contemplation in Christianity

Within Catholic Christianity, there is also a long history of distinguishing different forms of prayer.

Discursive meditation may involve reflecting upon scripture, the life of Jesus, or a particular spiritual truth.

Contemplative prayer, in some classical descriptions, involves a more receptive, loving attention to God that is not primarily concerned with developing thoughts about God.

Practices such as lectio divina may include reading, reflection, prayer, and a movement toward silent contemplation.

Other approaches, including Centering Prayer, employ a sacred word as a means of returning from distracting thoughts toward a receptive disposition before God.

These practices are not all the same, and Christian contemplative theology contains important distinctions between acquired methods and contemplation understood as a gift of grace.

But this diversity helped me understand why I had so often been confused.

Sometimes people used the word contemplation to describe the method.

Sometimes they used it to describe the more receptive experience toward which the method was directed.

And sometimes they seemed to move between these meanings without making the distinction explicit.

I had been looking for a clear explanation of something that was not always clearly named.

What Namkhai Norbu Helped Me Understand

Looking back over these encounters, I can see why Namkhai Norbu’s teachings were so important to me.

He offered a distinction that allowed me to recognize the difference between engaging in a contemplative activity and the Dzogchen understanding of contemplation as abiding in the natural state.

It was not simply a matter of thinking more deeply.

Nor was it a matter of making the mind blank.

In Dzogchen, the natural state is not produced by suppressing thoughts or manufacturing a special experience. Its recognition is traditionally introduced and clarified through authentic teaching and practice.

The Tibetan term rigpa is often translated as awareness or knowledge, but it has a precise significance within Dzogchen that should not be reduced to ordinary consciousness or the simple fact that we are awake.

As I listened to these teachings, I began to recognize a relationship between rigpa and what I had understood as Buddha nature.

I am not suggesting that these terms have identical meanings in every Buddhist school.

Rather, I began to sense that the teachings were pointing toward a possibility I had long been trying to understand.

An awakened dimension of experience that is not something the ordinary thinking mind can manufacture through effort alone.

And perhaps that was the most important change in my understanding.

I no longer needed to regard contemplation simply as another activity for the mind to perform.

The Difference Between Contemplation and Contemplation

So what is the difference?

Perhaps we can begin with something very simple.

Imagine sitting quietly with the question:

What is awareness?

You might think about the question.

You might recall teachings you have heard, consider philosophical explanations, examine your experiences, or compare different understandings.

That is contemplation in the sense of thoughtful reflection.

You are contemplating a subject.

Now imagine allowing the question to become quiet.

Not because you have discovered the perfect answer.

Not because you have successfully stopped thinking.

But because, for a moment, there is no longer a need to continue constructing an answer.

You may notice sounds, sensations, thoughts, or the space around you.

There is no requirement to hold on to any particular experience.

This simple experiment is not, by itself, the realization of rigpa or a substitute for Dzogchen instruction. But it may offer a small experiential glimpse of why object-directed reflection and non-discursive presence are not the same thing.

One involves considering an experience.

The other invites us to notice what remains when we are no longer deliberately occupied with considering it.

Both may have value.

Both may have a place in spiritual life.

But they are not the same experience.

And sometimes, knowing that difference can save us years of confusion.

Returning to This Morning

As I sit here this morning, my mind continues to do what minds do.

Thoughts arise.

Some disappear almost immediately.

Others seem particularly interesting and invite me to follow them.

Occasionally, I find myself halfway through an imaginary conversation before realizing that I have been carried away by it.

And then I notice.

There is no great drama.

No spiritual accomplishment to announce.

No need to criticize myself for having become distracted.

Just another opportunity to become familiar with what is happening.

After decades of living with chronic illness, I have also become increasingly aware of the difference between striving to become someone else and learning to meet the life that is actually here.

Some days my mind is relatively quiet.

Other days it is anything but quiet.

Some days my body allows me to do a little more.

Other days even the simplest activities may be difficult.

But perhaps contemplation need not become another measure of how well I am performing.

Perhaps the invitation is to discover a different relationship with experience itself.

I do not claim to have mastered that discovery.

I am still learning.

And perhaps that is part of the beauty of it.

An Invitation to Contemplate

If you have read this far, perhaps you might enjoy a small experiment.

Consider for a moment the question:

What is it like to be aware?

You may find yourself thinking about awareness, describing it, or remembering something you have learned.

There is nothing wrong with that.

That is one kind of contemplation.

And then, if you wish, allow the question to rest.

There is no need to answer it.

No need to make anything happen.

No need to achieve a special state.

Perhaps there are sounds around you.

Perhaps thoughts continue arising.

Perhaps there is discomfort, restlessness, peacefulness, or simply the ordinary experience of being here.

Whatever is present, there is no requirement to turn it into something else.

And if nothing particularly interesting happens, that is perfectly all right, too.

The invitation is not a test.

It is simply an opportunity to notice the difference between thinking about experience and allowing experience to be present without continually explaining it.

For me, this distinction has been one of the most helpful discoveries in my contemplative life.

And I hope that sharing it may spare someone else a little of the confusion I experienced along the way.

Perhaps the next time we hear the word contemplation, we might pause long enough to wonder what the speaker actually means.

Are we being invited to think deeply?

To inquire?

To practice a method of meditation?

Or to recognize something that cannot be reached merely by thinking about it?

The same word.

Two very different experiences.

And perhaps a doorway that has been waiting quietly all along.

May our inquiry deepen our understanding, our understanding soften our hearts, and our practice benefit all beings.

May all beings find peace.

A Note from the Author

Richard Silverman is an independent writer exploring compassion, contemplative living, and the quiet possibilities of finding peace and hope amid life’s challenges.

His writing is shared freely, in the hope that it may offer a little companionship, encouragement, or inspiration along the way.

If these reflections have been meaningful to you, and you would like to help sustain this work, you are warmly invited to support his writing through PayPal.

Thank you for being here. 🙏🪷


Discover more from Inspirations of Love and Hope

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Feel free to leave a comment below.