Exploring the Origins of Thought: A Synthesis of Jung, Ramana Maharshi, Kabbalah, and Tibetan Buddhism

In our journey to understand the nature of thoughts and the Self, we find ourselves drawing from the wisdom of various traditions—Jungian psychology, Vedanta as taught by Ramana Maharshi, the mystical insights of Kabbalah, and the profound teachings of Tibetan Buddhism. These perspectives, though rooted in different cultural and philosophical backgrounds, converge in fascinating ways, offering a profound understanding of where thoughts come from and where they go.

The Self: A Jungian Perspective

Carl Jung’s concept of the Self is expansive, encompassing both the conscious and unconscious aspects of the psyche. In Jungian thought, the Self is not just the sum of our conscious awareness but also includes the vast, often hidden, realm of the unconscious. Yet, Jung’s Self goes even further—it includes the totality of our being, which can be seen as connected to the divine. In this view, the Self is also God, the Infinite, the Eternal—encompassing everything, with nothing excluded.

Ein Sof and the Infinite Source

In Kabbalistic tradition, this concept of the Infinite is referred to as Ein Sof, meaning “without end.” Ein Sof represents the boundless, formless aspect of God, from which all creation emerges. It is the source of all existence, the primordial void from which thoughts and realities arise.

When we combine this with Jung’s understanding, we see that thoughts can be considered as arising from Ein Sof—the infinite potential. They emerge from the stillness, the formless void, moving first into the unconscious mind. From there, they bubble up into conscious awareness, manifesting in a way that we can perceive and reflect upon.

The Vedantic View: Ramana Maharshi on the Self

Ramana Maharshi’s teachings on the Self resonate deeply with these ideas. He teaches that the true Self is pure awareness, beyond both the conscious and unconscious mind. The thoughts that arise within us, whether they seem to come from the unconscious or are immediately conscious, are all manifestations within this pure awareness.

In Ramana’s framework, the conscious mind and the unconscious mind are both part of the egoic self—the sense of individual identity that is ultimately an illusion. However, by engaging in self-inquiry, we can trace our thoughts back to their true origin—the pure, infinite awareness that Ramana equates with the Self or Atman. This is the same awareness that Jung might refer to as the totality of the Self, and that Kabbalists understand as arising from Ein Sof.

The Tibetan Buddhist Perspective: All Phenomena as Ornaments of the Dharmakaya

Tibetan Buddhism offers a similar understanding but expresses it through the rich metaphor of the Dharmakaya, the truth body of the Buddha. According to these teachings, everything that arises—every thought, every perception, every experience—is an ornament of the Dharmakaya. This means that all phenomena are expressions of the ultimate reality, which is pure, unconditioned awareness or Buddha nature.

There is a common saying in Tibetan Buddhism: “All phenomena are the ornaments of the Dharmakaya,” or “All sound is the sound of Dharma; all sight is the display of Dharma.” This view suggests that everything we perceive, everything we experience, is not separate from the ultimate reality but is a manifestation of it. Just as thoughts arise from and dissolve back into Ein Sof or the Self, in Tibetan Buddhism, they are seen as temporary displays of the Dharmakaya, arising from the vastness of Buddha nature.

Buddha’s Enlightenment: Recognizing Mara as the Self

This understanding is beautifully illustrated in the story of Buddha’s enlightenment under the Bodhi tree. As Siddhartha Gautama sat in deep meditation, Mara—the personification of illusion and desire—appeared to tempt him and distract him from his path to enlightenment. Mara represented all the fears, desires, and illusions that arise within the mind.

However, instead of engaging with Mara as an external force, the Buddha recognized that Mara was not separate from himself. He famously said to Mara, “I know you. You are a creation of my own mind.” In that moment, by recognizing that Mara was merely a projection of his own thoughts, the Buddha disempowered Mara completely. Mara dissolved, and with that, Siddhartha Gautama achieved enlightenment, becoming the Buddha.

This moment is a powerful example of self-realization. By recognizing that thoughts, desires, and fears are not external realities but manifestations of the mind, the Buddha transcended them. In the same way, we can see that our thoughts, no matter how powerful they may seem, arise from and dissolve back into the infinite Self, the ultimate reality.

The Quantum Nature of Thought

In many ways, this understanding is mirrored in the discoveries of quantum physics. Particles, which seem solid and real, are actually 99.99% empty space. They appear and disappear from the quantum field so rapidly that they seem solid and continuous, much like how thoughts arise and dissolve within our consciousness. The solidity of our thoughts—or indeed our reality—is an illusion, a fleeting manifestation from the infinite potential that is the true Self.

Practical Application: Self-Inquiry and Meditation

Understanding thoughts as arising from Ein Sof or as ornaments of the Dharmakaya, and recognizing them as internal projections like Mara, can profoundly inform our practice of self-inquiry and meditation. When a thought arises, we can trace it back, not just through the layers of consciousness and unconsciousness but beyond, into the infinite source. This practice can help us see the impermanence and illusory nature of thoughts and, by extension, of the ego itself.

Through this inquiry, we can begin to experience the Self not just as a concept but as a living reality—the infinite awareness from which all arises and to which all returns.

Conclusion

This synthesis of Jungian psychology, Ramana Maharshi’s Vedanta, Kabbalistic mysticism, Tibetan Buddhism, and the story of Buddha’s enlightenment offers a rich, multifaceted understanding of the nature of thought and the Self. It invites us to see beyond the surface of our thoughts and experiences, recognizing them as temporary manifestations of the infinite. Whether through self-inquiry, meditation, or contemplation of these ideas, we are invited to explore the deeper reality of the Self—an exploration that can lead to profound spiritual awakening and insight.

🙏🕊️🙏