The Eternal Self and the Three States of Experience: Waking, Dreaming, and Deep Sleep

In the teachings of Advaita Vedanta, one of the most profound insights is the distinction between the transient states of consciousness—waking, dreaming, and deep sleep—and the eternal, unchanging Self. Pravrajika Devyanandaprana eloquently explores this concept in her teachings on self-inquiry, offering a deep understanding of the nature of awareness and the true Self.

The Three States of Experience

1. Waking State (Jagrat)

• Description: The waking state is the most familiar to us, where we engage with the external world through our senses. In this state, we are aware of our body, thoughts, emotions, and the physical environment around us. The waking state is characterized by our active involvement in the world and a strong identification with our physical body and mind.
• Relation to the Self: In the waking state, we often equate our identity with the body and mind. However, through the practice of self-inquiry, we begin to see that our true nature, the Self, is the unchanging awareness that witnesses all these experiences. We are not merely the body or the mind but the awareness that perceives them.

1. Dream State (Svapna)

• Description: The dream state occurs when the mind creates experiences independent of the external world, typically during sleep. In this state, we encounter a world created entirely by our mind, where we might identify with a dream body, experience emotions, and encounter various scenarios.
• Relation to the Self: The dream state shows us how transient and subjective our experiences can be. Just as a dream is a creation of the mind, our waking experiences are also shaped by our perceptions and thoughts. The Self, however, remains constant, witnessing both the waking and dream states without being affected by them.

1. Deep Sleep State (Sushupti)

• Description: The deep sleep state is characterized by the absence of mental activity and sensory experience. In this state, the mind is not active, and there are no thoughts, perceptions, or objects of awareness. It is often described as a state of profound rest and rejuvenation.
• Relation to the Self: Swamiji offers a profound insight by describing deep sleep as the “experience of absence, not the absence of experience.” In this state, there is an absence of objects—no pratyayas or mental events—but the Self, pure awareness, still persists. While the deep sleep state is free from the fluctuations of the mind and closely resembles the pristine mind or Brahman, it is not fully equated with the realization of these states because there is no conscious awareness of the Self’s true nature.

Additional Clarification:

• While the deep sleep state is characterized by the absence of mental activity and sensory experience, it is still considered a state of the mind. In this state, the mind is in a dormant, unmanifest condition—free from fluctuations, yet not entirely absent. It is a state where the mind rests in potentiality, closely resembling the pure awareness of Atman. However, full realization of Atman requires conscious awareness, which is not present in deep sleep. Thus, while deep sleep offers a glimpse into the nature of Atman, it is not equivalent to Atman itself.

The Invariable Self: The Eternal Witness

Swamiji emphasizes that the true Self, or Atman, is the one invariable presence that persists through all three states of consciousness. The waking, dreaming, and deep sleep states are transient; they come and go, but the Self remains constant. This Self is the pure awareness that witnesses all experiences without being affected by them.

• Mind as the Variable: The waking and dream states are considered states of the mind because they are conditioned by mental activities, sensory inputs, and subconscious processes. In the deep sleep state, however, the mind is dormant and free from fluctuations, closely resembling the pure awareness of Atman, yet it is still considered a state of the mind.
• The Self as the Invariable: Despite the changes in the mind’s states during waking and dreaming, and its quiescence in deep sleep, the Self remains unchanged. This unchanging awareness is the true essence of who we are—beyond the body, mind, and sensory experiences. It is the stable, undisturbed witness that remains present, regardless of the mind’s fluctuations.

Deep Sleep, Pristine Mind, and Brahman

The deep sleep state, where there is an absence of objects and mental events, can be seen as a state of pure potentiality. It is closer to the pristine mind or Brahman because it is free from the distractions and fluctuations of the mind. However, it is not the full realization of these states because, in deep sleep, there is still an absence of conscious awareness of one’s true nature as the Self.

• Pristine Mind: In some traditions, “pristine mind” refers to a state of pure, unconditioned awareness that is naturally calm, clear, and open. The deep sleep state, free from mental activity, resembles this pristine state but lacks the conscious recognition of it.
• Brahman: Brahman is the ultimate reality in Advaita Vedanta, the infinite, unchanging truth that underlies all existence. The deep sleep state, with its absence of dualistic experiences, is closer to Brahman, but full realization requires the conscious awareness of the Self as Brahman, which is absent in deep sleep.

The Metaphor of the Sky

A helpful metaphor to understand this teaching is to think of the Self as the sky and the three states as passing clouds. The clouds—whether stormy or peaceful—come and go, but the sky remains untouched, vast, and unchanging. Similarly, the Self remains pure and constant, while the mind’s states pass through.

Transcending the Three States: The Practice of Self-Inquiry

Through self-inquiry, we can transcend identification with the transient states of the mind and recognize our true nature as the unchanging Self. By consistently asking, “Who am I?” or “What am I?” we disentangle our identity from the fleeting experiences of the mind and connect more deeply with the Self.

• Mindfulness and Awareness: In daily life, cultivating mindfulness helps us stay connected to this invariable Self. By being aware of the transient nature of thoughts, emotions, and experiences, we can maintain a sense of detachment and recognize that the true “I” is always present, beyond these changing states.
• Continual Inquiry: Practicing self-inquiry, especially during transitions between waking, dreaming, and sleep, deepens our realization that we are not the changing mind but the awareness that witnesses all changes.

Swamiji’s teachings remind us that while the mind and its states are transient, the Self is eternal. By recognizing and connecting with this unchanging awareness, we can find stability and peace, transcending the fluctuations of the mind and realizing our true nature.

Reflective Questions:

• How do you perceive each of the three states of experience in your own life?
• In what ways can you recognize the invariable Self amidst the changing states of mind?
• How has the practice of self-inquiry influenced your understanding of your true Self?

Feel free to share your thoughts and experiences in the comments. Your reflections can help create a richer community of practice and understanding.

Below is the original source video of the lecture with Swami Parvajika Devyanandaprana, from which these blog posts were inspired. Here you can explore the insightful teachings that have profoundly shaped the content and perspectives shared in this blog.

🙏🕊️🙏